Skip to main content
cspdailynews.com - Convenience Store News
  • Industry News
    • Preparing for Extreme Weather
    • Top Stories
      Top news stories about the convenience store, petroleum retailing industry
    • Community Outreach
      Convenience store retailers giving back to their communities
    • Corporate News
      Corporate news affecting the convenience store industry
    • Marketing Strategies
      Convenience store marketing strategy ideas & news
    • Regulation & Legislation
      Regulation & legislation news affecting the convenience store industry
    • Rumors
      The latest scuttlebutt, rumors & fun in the convenience store industry
    • Technology
      Technology news affecting the convenience store industry
    • Special Reports
      Convenience store trends, insights and ideas for understanding your c-store customers and marketing to the right audience in the right way.
    • 2017 Consumer Report
      Exclusive research: How are millennials changing the c-store experience?
    • Top Convenience Stores
      CSP’s annual list of the largest chains in the convenience store industry
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • enmarket
      Enmarket Assumes Operations of 34 E-Z Shops
    • Mergers & Acquisitions News
      Mergers & acquisitions news affecting the convenience store industry
  • Fuels
    • Weigel’s Giving 12 Customers Free Gas for a Year
    • Fuels News
      The latest news on petroleum, diesel and alternative fuel retailing
    • Fuels Technology & Equipment
      The latest fuels technology and equipment news
    • Wholesale Fuels Prices
      The latest wholesale, rack fuel price news
    • Retail Fuels Prices
      The latest retail gasoline, fuel price news
    • Retail Fuel Prices Lookup
      Compare lowest retail prices
    • Fuels 50
      The most effective fuel brands in convenience retailing
  • Data
    • Beverages Data
      Beverage category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Foodservice Data
      Foodservice category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • General Merchandise Data
      General merchandise category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Services Data
      C-store services data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Snacks & Candy Data
      Snacks and candy category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Tobacco Data
      Tobacco, cigarette and e-cig category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Mystery Shop
      Report cards from CSP's annual customer-service survey
    • Category Management Handbook
      Complete, full-year, c-store-specific sales data in major in-store product categories.
  • Sponsored Content
    • Classifieds
      Property for Sale and Help Wanted Classifieds
    • Video Learning Center
      Related c-store videos
    • Webevents
      Register for Live Web Events and On Demand recordings from the c-store industry
  • Events
cspdailynews.com - Convenience Store News
  • Industry News
    • Preparing for Extreme Weather
    • Top Stories
      Top news stories about the convenience store, petroleum retailing industry
    • Community Outreach
      Convenience store retailers giving back to their communities
    • Corporate News
      Corporate news affecting the convenience store industry
    • Marketing Strategies
      Convenience store marketing strategy ideas & news
    • Regulation & Legislation
      Regulation & legislation news affecting the convenience store industry
    • Rumors
      The latest scuttlebutt, rumors & fun in the convenience store industry
    • Technology
      Technology news affecting the convenience store industry
    • Special Reports
      Convenience store trends, insights and ideas for understanding your c-store customers and marketing to the right audience in the right way.
    • 2017 Consumer Report
      Exclusive research: How are millennials changing the c-store experience?
    • Top Convenience Stores
      CSP’s annual list of the largest chains in the convenience store industry
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • enmarket
      Enmarket Assumes Operations of 34 E-Z Shops
    • Mergers & Acquisitions News
      Mergers & acquisitions news affecting the convenience store industry
  • Fuels
    • Weigel’s Giving 12 Customers Free Gas for a Year
    • Fuels News
      The latest news on petroleum, diesel and alternative fuel retailing
    • Fuels Technology & Equipment
      The latest fuels technology and equipment news
    • Wholesale Fuels Prices
      The latest wholesale, rack fuel price news
    • Retail Fuels Prices
      The latest retail gasoline, fuel price news
    • Retail Fuel Prices Lookup
      Compare lowest retail prices
    • Fuels 50
      The most effective fuel brands in convenience retailing
  • Data
    • Beverages Data
      Beverage category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Foodservice Data
      Foodservice category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • General Merchandise Data
      General merchandise category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Services Data
      C-store services data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Snacks & Candy Data
      Snacks and candy category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Tobacco Data
      Tobacco, cigarette and e-cig category data for the convenience store retail industry.
    • Mystery Shop
      Report cards from CSP's annual customer-service survey
    • Category Management Handbook
      Complete, full-year, c-store-specific sales data in major in-store product categories.
  • Sponsored Content
    • Classifieds
      Property for Sale and Help Wanted Classifieds
    • Video Learning Center
      Related c-store videos
    • Webevents
      Register for Live Web Events and On Demand recordings from the c-store industry
  • Events

News:

  • Beverages
  • Foodservice
  • General Merchandise
  • Services
  • Snacks & Candy
  • Tobacco
Search form
 
Fuels News, Prices & Analysis>>Fuels Analysis

Refiners, Small Retailers Fight RIN System

New coalition pushes to move obligation further downstream
Samantha Oller
Fuels News, Prices & Analysis
>
Fuels Analysis
August 18, 2016

WASHINGTON -- When it comes to the fight against escalating RIN prices, refiners are finding an unexpected ally.

The Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) requires refiners as obligated parties to blend a set quantity of renewable fuel such as ethanol or biodiesel into transportation fuel each year. Refiners can blend actual fuel or, if they are going to come up short on their targets, buy Renewable Identification Numbers (RINs), which act as a credit toward their obligation, from other blenders such as large fuel retailers.

Whenever the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) raises blending quotas, as it did for 2016, RIN prices tend to rise. Refiners argue that the quotas surpass the amount of biofuels they can legally blend into transportation fuel—or 10%—and that demand growth has not been strong enough to keep pace with the increasing quotas. That makes RINs more valuable as a way to meet their obligations.

 

In 2016, refiners are set to hit a record in RIN spending, according to a recent Reuters analysis. That’s because RIN prices are jumping—up 25% in second-quarter 2016 vs. the same time a year ago, based on an analysis of figures from the Oil Price Information Service (OPIS).

This spending on RINs has put incredible pressure on refiners’ profits, which already are suffering as fuel stockpiles swell. Reuters estimates that 10 of the major U.S. refiners spent a minimum of $1.1 billion during the first half of 2016 on buying RINs. If this pace keeps up, they are set to break a previous record of $1.3 billion in 2013.

Each time RIN prices escalate, refiners and their representatives ask—and sometimes sue—the EPA to shift the point of obligation downstream to fuel distributors who blend at the rack. In early August, the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers trade group petitioned the EPA to redefine an obligated party as “the entity that holds title to the gasoline or diesel fuel, immediately prior to the sale from the bulk transfer/terminal system … to a wholesaler, retailer or ultimate consumer.” 

Now some fuel retailers are jumping into the debate—on the side of refiners. The Small Retailers Coalition is a Washington, D.C.-based organization that formed this past July, right at a time when RIN values were soaring toward the 2013 high. The group’s founder is a familiar, respected industry veteran: Bill Douglass, chairman and founder of Douglass Distributing, Sherman, Texas, which has more than 20 Lone Star convenience stores and supplies more than 170 sites. 

Late this past July, the group sent a letter to Janet McCabe, acting assistant director for the EPA’s Office of Air and Radiation. In the letter, Douglass asks the EPA to shift the point of obligation down to the rack.

“The big driver is frankly survival,” Douglass told CSP Daily News. From his perspective, many large chains have an unfair fuel profit advantage thanks to their ability to raise massive revenue from selling RINs. For example, Murphy USA, which Douglass competes with in Texas, generated $117.5 million in 2015 from RINs.

In the current market, Douglass said his competitors are selling at a loss of 1 or more cents per gallon (CPG), but are still able to be profitable thanks to RINs. Douglass’ sites may try to meet their street price, but it can become financially crushing.

“The cost isn’t an issue if you’re getting a 10-cent ethanol RIN and 15-cent biofuel RIN,” said Douglass. “That’s all the margin you need. So they can just sit there and beat you to death.”

While Douglass might describe his company as a “small marketer,” size is relative. The company often buys more than 100 million gallons annually, making its volume modest but not insignificant. But because it is branded, it does not earn RINs for blending at the rack—instead, its supplier does. As far as Douglass can tell, its supplier is not passing down any savings from the RINs. Meanwhile, his large competition is able sell aggressively and still profit.

“If you’ve got a margin that equals my annual fuel margin to play with, then I’m at a distinct disadvantage when you’ve got a government subsidy of the same amount,” said Douglass.

NACS and SIGMA do not support moving the point of obligation, arguing that blenders’ ability to comply would be dictated by refiners, who would have leverage and incentive to raise prices. “We feel moving the point of obligation would actually harm retailers and could lead to problems with fuel supply, therefore leading to higher costs to the consumer,” Paige Anderson, NACS director of government relations, told CSP Daily News.

The Small Retailers Coalition is small, with about 50 members so far. But its main goal is simply to get the EPA to reconsider whether the current RIN setup is helping the agency meet the intention of the RFS.

“Congress intended it to encourage use of alternative fuels,” said Douglass. “But Congress never intended it to be stacked in the favor of a few. They intended it as an incentive for everybody to push renewable fuels.”

He estimates that his chances of reasoning with the EPA are good, and expects the agency will be fair. The office of McCabe told Douglass the agency is analyzing his comments, and taking them seriously. Douglass hopes his letter changes the dynamic.

“The government’s picking winners and losers, and right now, they’re picking the big guys to be the winners,” said Douglass. “If we don’t act like them, we won’t be able to stay. In other words, if we don’t get the RIN, we can’t compete with them.”

Related Topics: 
alternative fuels, earnings, fuel prices, fuel volume, margins, petroleum, public company, taxes
Related Content
2017 RFS Volumes: A Modest Proposal?5/19/2016
A 'More Realistic' RFS?5/29/2015
Does the RFS Need to Get 'Back on Track'?3/25/2016

Recommended by CSP

Recommended content

Preparing for Extreme Weather

Recommended content

8 Ways to Weather the Next Storm

Recommended content

SOI: 2017 Beverage Sales Hint at Opportunities for C-Stores

enmarket

Recommended content

Enmarket Assumes Operations of 34 E-Z Shops

gopuff

Recommended content

How GoPuff Is Stealing Your Stoners

coca cola

Recommended content

Coca-Cola Partners With In-Car Retail Platform Cargo

e-cig brands

Recommended content

FDA to Crack Down on E-Cigarettes

zzzquil

Recommended content

Vicks Puts ZzzQuil in Gummy Form

starbucks

Recommended content

Starbucks to Close U.S. Stores for Racial-Bias Training

lettuce

Recommended content

Outbreak of E. Coli Traced Back to Lettuce

Top Stories

Corporate News

8 Ways to Weather the Next Storm

Beef up insurance, stuck up on seasonal items, install a generator and...

Beverages

SOI: 2017 Beverage Sales Hint at Opportunities for C-Stores

Total store sales, gross profit dollars improve for alcohol and...

enmarket
Mergers & Acquisitions News

Enmarket Assumes Operations of 34 E-Z Shops

Will begin rebranding of South Carolina chain
gopuff
Technology

How GoPuff Is Stealing Your Stoners

A guide to 4/20 marketing and sales

coca cola
Beverages

Coca-Cola Partners With In-Car Retail Platform Cargo

Beverage maker sees ride-hailing vehicles as a 'new distribution channel'.
e-cig brands
Tobacco

FDA to Crack Down on E-Cigarettes

Commissioner promises action soon to curb use by teenagers
CSPnet.com - Convenience Store News
Subscribe now!
Get CSP in your inbox

Resources

 

Top Convenience Stores

CSP’s annual list of the largest chains in the convenience-store industry.
 

Category Management Handbook

Category sales performance in Beverages, Candy, General Merchandise, Packaged Food/Foodservice and Snacks.
 

State of the Industry

After three years of record profits, is the party over? Plus, cross-channel competition, economic indicators and growing product categories.
 

Rumors

The hottest scuttlebutt, rumors and fun in the convenience-store industry.
 

Convenience Store Products

The latest information on products and trends in the convenience-store and foodservice industries.
 

Grand Openings

Peek inside new convenience stores to uncover the best in retail store design across North America.

Trending stories

v8 protein shake

Campbell Soup Discontinues V8 Protein Lines

Category News

Campbell Soup Discontinues V8 Protein Lines

Category News

Newport Gaining Momentum

Industry News & Analysis

'Weird' but not Critical

Fuels News, Prices & Analysis

Phillips 66 Rises Again

CSPnet.com - Convenience Store News
Since 2003 CSP magazine has ranked No. 1 in readership and market share over all other industry publications. C-store marketers have identified CSP as the preferred magazine source for their trade marketing communications. With industry-leading, highly targeted circulation to more than 100,000 subscribers, CSP reaches the key convenience retailing decision-makers fifteen times a year.
April 2018 issue of CSP Magazine
View CSP Magazine Digital Edition
View CSP Magazine Archives
CSP Products
Copyright © Winsight, LLC. 2018
  • About CSP Magazine
  • About C-Store Products
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise
  • CSP Editorial Staff
  • Subscribe