Technology/Services

What if every category manager led with loyalty?

Even small companies can make loyalty a priority, says Mike Templeton of NexChapter
In a loyalty-driven organization, marketing and merchandising are interconnected.
In a loyalty-driven organization, marketing and merchandising are interconnected. | CSP Staff

What if instead of having one loyalty manager on a c-store’s team, every category manager led with loyalty?

That’s the question Mike Templeton, partner and vice president at Des Moines, Iowa-based NexChapter, asked during a session on Feb. 26 at CSP’s Convenience Retailing University in Austin, Texas. 

While this might be easier for larger companies, smaller companies may be better positioned to lead with loyalty, Templeton said. With fewer people on the team, roles naturally overlap. 

As companies expand, accountability and focus within loyalty tend to be divided into different areas, Templeton said. But the person leading category management or merchandising often carries responsibility for loyalty as well. And when those functions sit together, loyalty stops being a side initiative, he said. It becomes embedded in everyday decisions, which is when the real impact begins to take shape, he said.

Templeton examined loyalty through a marketing and merchandising lens and demonstrated how it connects the two.

From a marketing perspective, loyalty centers on the customer proposition—what the brand is offering, the structure of the program, how customers earn rewards, what they earn and the rules that guide participation. Marketing focuses on defining the value exchange, he said.

From a merchandising perspective, loyalty looks different, according to Templeton. It’s about understanding who the customers are, how they’re segmented, which audiences to prioritize, what promotions to run and how pricing strategies align with those efforts.

At first glance, these responsibilities may seem separate. But in a loyalty-driven organization, they are interconnected.

Companies invest in loyalty not to send better emails, but to make smarter decisions, reach more customers, and ultimately grow the business, he said.

Members help make our journalism possible. Become a CSP member today and unlock exclusive benefits, including unlimited access to all of our content. Sign up here.

Multimedia

Exclusive Content

Foodservice

Technomic’s 2026 State of the Menu offers foodservice strategies for c-stores

Report highlights value-driven menus, trend adoption and booming beverage categories to boost sales

Mergers & Acquisitions

Brand counts more than store count

Lessons from The Pantry, Arko and EG America reveal the risks of rapid expansion and the value of brand-focused reinvention: Morrison

Foodservice

How Arko is keeping up with QSRs

GPM Investments’ vice president of foodservice and QSR brands shares highlights of fas craves program

Trending

More from our partners