Fresh foods and a wide variety of dispensed and packaged beverages are a hallmark of the family-owned Newcomb Oil's FiveStar convenience stores in Kentucky, Indiana and Tennessee. The company is up by three locations compared to last year's store count, from 93 to 96 sites. Most of the stores are in the chain's home state of Kentucky. FiveStar locations also have a strong foodservice offer. Breakfast choices include biscuits, sandwiches and breakfast plates with a customer's choice of items. Hot deli foods, as well as hamburgers and sandwiches, are available at lunch. Salads, subs, wraps and sandwiches are on the menu all day. Newcomb Oil also distributes fuel to about 30 dealers. FiveStar keeps customers engaged with an active Facebook page. Customer comments frequently mention friendly service and clean restrooms.
For benchmarking purposes, store counts are as of Jan. 1, 2026.
| Headquarters: | Bardstown, Kentucky |
|---|---|
| No. of Stores: | 96 |
| Rank: | 71 |
| Rank Last Year: | 76 |
| Website: | https://www.fivestarfoodmart.com/ |