Company News

Mystery Shop 2018: How to Rate Convenience

The ingredients for success: consistent in-stocks, friendly staff and a 'white glove' level of cleanliness

CHICAGO -- In the days of ever-increasing competition from dollar stores, hypermarkets and the burgeoning digital disruptors, c-stores must hold onto what separates them from the pack: convenience.

Today, long checkout times, dirty restrooms and empty cooler doors are a recipe for disaster. Meanwhile, the ingredients for success are a combination of consistent in-stocks, friendly staff and, as one retailer put it, a “white glove” level of cleanliness that make customers not only want to return but also to recommend the store to friends.

For 14 years, CSP and Intouch Insight Ltd., Ottawa, Ontario, and Fort Hill, S.C., have conducted an annual mystery shop on 10 volunteer chains. The methodology has evolved over time in response to participant and retailer feedback on the most helpful metrics for measuring operational success. Consider it our recipe for assessing the magic behind convenience.




Create a structure

The CSP/Intouch Insight Mystery Shop begins with an announced, scheduled audit in which store staff are aware an auditor is visiting, along with a separate, true mystery shop, in which an undercover shopper rates staff behavior.

Pick criteria

Decide which areas of the store to assess, what to observe or measure and develop a questionnaire. For convenience stores, metrics such as wait times, cleanliness and employee friendliness are critical.


Write questions

Was the ceiling clean (tile and vents)? Was the restroom(s) properly stocked? Was the temperature of the sandwich cooler between 32 and 41 degrees Fahrenheit? Were you shown any sign of gratitude or given sincere thanks when leaving the store? Did the cashier make you feel like a valued customer?

Assign weight

As the study has evolved, CSP and Intouch Insight have picked a winner after giving more weight (75%) to the revealed audit over the true mystery shop (25%). The program prioritizes physical store-level execution (revealed audits) but still gives weight to how staff relates to customers (mystery shop).

Analyze data

About 1,500 audits and mystery shops led to the results of the 2018 study.

Reveal results

And the winner is …


Revealed-Audit Winner (weighted 75%)


Covert-Shop Winner (weighted 25%)


Would You Recommend the Store to Others?

Intouch Insight researchers valued this question as an indicator of customer satisfaction and ultimately the products and services that define convenience. Unfortunately, this year’s results showed that customers were slightly less pleased with their c-store experience than in 2017.


Click here to read more about the results of this year's mystery shop.

Photograph by Matt Roth

Members help make our journalism possible. Become a CSP member today and unlock exclusive benefits, including unlimited access to all of our content. Sign up here.


Exclusive Content

Mergers & Acquisitions

Casey’s Keeping Lone Star Brand

Retailer not completely rebranding Texas stores acquired from Douglass Distributing


7 in 10 C-Store Operators Plan Menu Enhancements in 2024

Technomic dives into how retailers can boost offerings, the rise in customer visits and more

Company News

C-Store People News for December 2023

Updates from Pilot Co., Cal's Convenience and more


More from our partners