Sheetz offers a plethora of sweet, dessert-inspired drinks, from Cake Batter Cream and Fluffer Nutter smoothies to a Reese’s Peanut Butter Hot Chocolate. But one notable, superindulgent standout on the beverage menu is its Cotton Candy Smoothie.

The bright blue, cream-and-sprinkles-topped smoothie captures the flavor of the retro and fluffy sugary treat. It found its way onto the chain’s permanent menu after winning a 2015 fan-generated smoothie “smackdown” contest against a Bubble Gum Smoothie limited-time offer.