Alltown Fresh offers customizable coffee creamers that satisfy both sugary and healthy cravings. They include classic cream and milk with white sugar and Splenda, as well as almond milk, coconut milk and hemp milk.

The stores also carry sugar made from monk fruit extract, cane sugar and zero-calorie sweetener. Its whipped toppings, sauces and powders for cold espresso beverages and smoothies include caramel and dark chocolate, maca powder, spirulina powder, cacao, avocado powder and almond butter.

Rutter’s offers eight rotating options for milk and coffee creamers, as well as a variety of syrups and sauces for cold-brew beverages, including chocolate, white chocolate, caramel, strawberry, peach, mango, French vanilla and a sugar-free option. The chain also offers toppings for its cold beverages such as blueberries, strawberries, chocolate chips and Oreo bits.

“These syrups and sauces are integrated for nearly all beverages at our stores,” White says. “We want to make them as customizable as possible.”